Were Joseph and Mary both from Tribe of Judah?
-
I seems to have this impression Jesus was descended from David through either of his parents.
-
Through Joseph... read the bible...Originally posted by Icemoon:I seems to have this impression Jesus was descended from David through either of his parents.
As to your first question in the title... hmmm not sure about Mary, but Joseph was if you follow it far back enough... -
Does not make sense for the fact:Originally posted by breytonhartge:Through Joseph... read the bible...
As to your first question in the title... hmmm not sure about Mary, but Joseph was if you follow it far back enough...
1. Jewish lineage is traced through the mother.
2. Joseph had no blood relations whatsoever with Jesus. -
Edit: Point 1 might be wrong .. I anyhow hantum one.
But Point 2 is a glaring mistake. Don't you all think so? -
I agree with what you say about point 2Originally posted by Icemoon:Edit: Point 1 might be wrong .. I anyhow hantum one.
But Point 2 is a glaring mistake. Don't you all think so?
Pls close this topic and ban Icemoon -
Originally posted by laurence82:I agree with what you say about point 2
Pls close this topic and ban Icemoon -
I don't understand this thread. abit KSM.Originally posted by Icemoon: 
-
This thread is as per topic.Originally posted by M©+square:I don't understand this thread. abit KSM.
Then brey said Joseph was descendant of David. Then I said Jesus no blood relations with Joseph.
Still KSM? -
Wrong,Originally posted by Icemoon:Does not make sense for the fact:
1. Jewish lineage is traced through the mother.
2. Joseph had no blood relations whatsoever with Jesus.
Jewish lineage is traced through the father... Judaism the religion is traced through the mother. -
Huh? I thought its clear.Originally posted by M©+square:I don't understand this thread. abit KSM.
Icemoon is asking whether jesus is a descendant of David. -
He is still born into Joseph's house so technically He is of the lineage of David of the house of Judah.Originally posted by Icemoon:This thread is as per topic.
Then brey said Joseph was descendant of David. Then I said Jesus no blood relations with Joseph.
Still KSM? -
because Icemoon asked something more than what meets the Eye.Originally posted by laurence82:Huh? I thought its clear.
Icemoon is asking whether jesus is a descendant of David.
-
care to give us insight?Originally posted by M©+square:because Icemoon asked something more than what meets the Eye. 
-
one word: very qian1 qiang2.Originally posted by breytonhartge:He is still born into Joseph's house so technically He is of the lineage of David of the house of Judah. -
How come religion is traced through mummy? I always wondered about this quirk.Originally posted by breytonhartge:Wrong,
Jewish lineage is traced through the father... Judaism the religion is traced through the mother. -
The Jews are a matriachal society.Originally posted by Icemoon:How come religion is traced through mummy? I always wondered about this quirk. -
Then they should trace the lineage through Mama? And inherit her tribe/surname instead.Originally posted by breytonhartge:The Jews are a matriachal society.
It is surprising the Jews are a matriachal society when it is male-dominated in almost every aspects. -
Initially it is the mothers role to teach the children about religion. That is just the way it has been set up. We can ask God the question later?Originally posted by Icemoon:Then they should trace the lineage through Mama? And inherit her tribe/surname instead.
It is surprising the Jews are a matriachal society when it is male-dominated in almost every aspects. -
Then Solomon, son of King David trained by his mother too?Originally posted by breytonhartge:Initially it is the mothers role to teach the children about religion. That is just the way it has been set up. We can ask God the question later? -
His mother train him to take proper showers.Originally posted by M©+square:Then Solomon, son of King David trained by his mother too? -
It's a weird switch.Originally posted by Icemoon:His mother train him to take proper showers.
But anyway, i believe to have answered my own question about lineage of Joseph and Mary. -
what's your question and your ans?Originally posted by M©+square:But anyway, i believe to have answered my own question about lineage of Joseph and Mary. -
Originally posted by Icemoon:what's your question and your ans?
My questions wasn't stated.Originally posted by M©+square:because Icemoon asked something more than what meets the Eye.
So does my answer.
nothing really spectacular anyway
Cheers! -
jus because Joseph nv contribute his sperms doesnt mean Jesus is not a descendant of David. In Jewish context, adopted son has full n equal rights as if he is the biological son.
in the same manner, all who come to Christ r adopted sons of God and the bible says we r co-heirs with Christ. -
Like I said .. very qian qiang. How many of the biblical heroes were adopted sons?Originally posted by NT2:jus because Joseph nv contribute his sperms doesnt mean Jesus is not a descendant of David. In Jewish context, adopted son has full n equal rights as if he is the biological son.
It is like .. any messiah-wannabe can just acknowledge a Davidic descendant as his father.